What cellphone carrier do you reccomend?

What cellphone provider do you re

  • Cingular

    Votes: 3 18.8%
  • AT&T

    Votes: 5 31.3%
  • Verizon

    Votes: 7 43.8%
  • T-Mobile

    Votes: 1 6.3%

  • Total voters
    16

epj3

Senior Member
Messages
7,370
Likes
0
Location
Lancaster, PA
#1
These are the carriers I have a choice of going with -- I want nextel but since I have absolutely no credit yet (haven't been 18 too long and have had no credit cards) they require a $500 deposit.

I live in a suburban area, and will be going to college in the suburbs. Cingular's singnal round here is horrible, and sprint - which I've had for the past few years -- is the worse carrier you could go with.
 

epj3

Senior Member
Messages
7,370
Likes
0
Location
Lancaster, PA
#3
Tom said:
I use Cingular, but I think ATT has the best deals right now.
Yea, AT&T also gives me a discount because of the college I am attending this fall.

The only thing that bugs me is their phone selection. I don't need a camera, but I do want a flip phone that has decent features, but won't cost $200 AFTER the rebate.

Verizon seems to have the best deals with phones -- LG makes decent phones. I hate cellphones, and think they are a scam. The only reason I have it is becuase all my friends have a phone, and I'd loose touch with everyone I know without a cellphone.
 
Messages
1,617
Likes
0
Location
Dallas TX, Kennesaw, GA
#4
I had Bell Atlantic in the East, now Verizon. I had AT&T locally for a few years and just changed to Verizon and they are much better here than AT&T. But I had no problems with AT&T in California, only Las Vegas. So I guess I am saying I don’t know for sure because I still think it depends on your area. I would think that Verizon should be a strong provider for your area though.
 
Messages
4,412
Likes
5
Location
Wayzata, MN
#7
everyone except me. and no, GSM isn't that bad. but when it first came out it was shadey and companies would always tell you its "only ok" so then people got all negative about it. I've had my GSM phone for almost a year now, and i've noticed a ton of improvements on coverage. it seriously seems like every month they expand the coverage area. best way to do it is either find a phone you really like and then find the best deal for it, or figure out where you are going to be, and find the best WSP for that area. I'm all about GSM now, ALLLLLL ABOUT IT
 
Messages
766
Likes
0
Location
Ames, IA / St. Paul, MN
#8
I have AT&T and no complaints. I had reception even out in the middle of rainy lake in Vouageurs national park. Seriously everywhere I've been I've had reception. I've been very satisfied.
 
Last edited:
Messages
401
Likes
0
Location
Chicago
#9
I copied this from Consumer Reports.

There are differences among the major services. Here are the ones that count.

Now that number portability has given consumers more freedom to switch, the major cell-phone carriers are advertising heavily to differentiate themselves from their competitors. Here are the differences that really matter, which you won’t necessarily see in the ads.




AT&T WIRELESS
How good Middling levels of customer satisfaction in our survey. Overloaded circuits have been a problem in several cities.
Turnover rate 29 percent.
Specials mMode, a catchall term for an array of features, many tied to an Internet connection, that deliver data to the phone. Also GoPhone, a variation on prepaid, no-contract calling plans.
Digital networks TDMA and GSM GSM phones can roam only on other GSM networks. The TDMA network is bigger and allows roaming on other TDMA or analog systems.




CINGULAR
How good Middling levels of customer satisfaction in our survey. Overloaded circuits have been a problem in several cities.
Turnover rate 32 percent.
Specials Rollover minutes, available on many calling plans, let you carry forward any unused calling time.
Digital networks TDMA and GSM. GSM phones can roam only on other GSM networks. The TDMA network is bigger and allows roaming on other TDMA or analog systems.




NEXTEL
How good Middling levels of customer satisfaction in our survey. Fewer problems than most with call connections, and average customer support.
Turnover rate 21 percent, lowest of the major companies.
Specials First to offer push-to-talk walkie-talkie service with a cell phone (.
Digital network Uses iDEN network. No roaming on other systems. Offers only Motorola phones.




SPRINT PCS
How good Wide variation in customer-satisfaction scores in our survey. Dropped calls and customer support have been problems.
Turnover rate 35 percent.
Specials Latest to offer push-to-talk service. PCS Vision service is a collection of features, many tied to an Internet connection. Its calling plans begin nighttime hours at 7 p.m., two hours earlier than others.
Digital network Uses CDMA. Can roam with other networks using CDMA or analog.




T-MOBILE
How good Wide variation in customer-satisfaction scores in our survey. Static on calls has been a problem.
Turnover rate 38 percent, highest of the major companies.
Specials Known as the value leader, with low per-minute rates (but not necessarily the best rates overall). Weekend rates begin on Fridays. Offers only 1-year contracts.
Digital network Uses GSM. Can roam only on other GSM systems.




VERIZON WIRELESS
How good Highest levels of customer satisfaction in our survey. Fewer problems with service availability and overloaded circuits.
Turnover rate 23 percent.
Specials Push-to-talk walkie-talkie service. Some calling plans tie wireless service in with regular local and long-distance calling, plus high-speed Internet access.
Digital network Uses CDMA. Can roam on other networks that use CDMA or analog.


I have Verizon and I like it. I rarely get dropped calls or no service.

BTW I would suggest you get A credit card. Pay it off every month no exceptions and never be late with a payment. Little credit with a good rating is better than no credit. We know you’re a good and responsible guy, but unfortunately you have to prove that to the banks.


ALPHABET SOUP: CELL-PHONE TERMS

Analog The original type of wireless techology. An important backup for emergencies, but being phased out.

CDMA Code Division Multiple Access. The format used by Sprint, Verizon, and some regional carriers. It assigns a digital code to keep the calls separate.

Cellular Also known as mobile or wireless. It’s a call-handling system composed of a network of antennas. A call is relayed from antenna to antenna.

Cellular band The part of the radio spectrum originally allocated for mobile-phone use. See also PCS band.

Dual band Denotes a phone that can operate in the cellular and PCS bands, which can broaden coverage.

Dual mode, tri-mode, multinetwork Denotes a phone that can use at least one digital format, analog technology, or both.

GSM Global System for Mobile Communications. A digital format that’s widely used in Europe and Asia. It keeps calls separate by assigning a slice of time to each caller. Used by AT&T and Cingular.

iDEN Integrated Digital Enhanced Network. Used only by Nextel in the U.S.

PCS band Personal Communications System band. A portion of the radio spectrum allocated to mobile-phone use. Sprint and T-Mobile are the largest companies in the PCS band.

PTT Push to Talk. Allows a cell phone to be used like a walkie-talkie.
Roaming The common practice of seeking a signal from a “partner” carrier to handle a call outside your home area.

SMS Short Message Service, or text messaging. Lets you send short text messages from one cell phone to another or from the Internet to a cell phone.

TDMA Time Division Multiple Access. The digital format used mainly by AT&T Wireless and Cingular. Similar to GSM.
 
Last edited:

epj3

Senior Member
Messages
7,370
Likes
0
Location
Lancaster, PA
#11
Sprint sucks major ______. (Fill in the blank)

I've had $35 plan with sprint for 2 years. For the first year, I was paying $40 after taxes, surcharges, and hidden BS fee's. Now I'm paying $47, and I havent changed 1 damn thing.
 
Messages
3,476
Likes
0
Location
Lincoln, CA
#12
I like Verizon. ATT supposedly got much better the last month or so, but they've been so bad for so long that I still have a bad taste in my mouth about them.

The "got better" part only refers to Southern California. My prior bad experiences with them extend to all of California and Las Vegas as well.
 

Ben

Active Member
Messages
576
Likes
0
Location
NY
#13
i have AT&T GSM with a sony ericson T306 phone that i got for $20. Like frolf said, it sucked about a year ago, but its MUCH better now and i have service almost everywhere. Im paying around $40 a month for 300 daytime minutes, free nights and weekends and free long distance.
 
Messages
243
Likes
0
Location
Oswego, IL
#14
I had Sprint for two years and hated it. Constanly dropping calls and not being able to get any kind of a signal in several office buildings.

I have now been with ATT Wireless for two years and would go with them again. Keep in mind though that cingular has bought out ATT Wireless and have given no indication as to weather your service will be interupted when the changeover occurs. Once this happens though, Cingular will have the broadest coverage (but their customer service sucks imo).
 


Top